• Follow us

Bhutan News

Opposition questions govt’s vision and plans - KuenselOnline

The government lacks clarity of vision and direction, the Opposition stated yesterday at its first press conference after assuming office.

This, the Opposition said is apparent from the modest targets of GDP growth, poverty reduction and gini-coefficient intended to achieve in the 12th Plan.

“It lacks ambition and clarity on what it wants to achieve,” the Opposition MP Dorji Wangdi said.

Delving into the 12th Plan, he said the biggest highlight of the Plan is the flagship programmes. All nine programmes, he said are tentative and that the government is not sure what they want to do.

Most of its popular pledges such as breastfeeding allowance, doing away with cutoff point and super specialist hospital are not in the Plan and not budgeted.

The common minimum infrastructure in the Plan, he said was quite similar to the first elected government’s common minimum programme such as electricity for all, telecommunication network for all and safe drinking water supply for all.

However, he said the activities for the common minimum infrastructure of the 12th Plan are small. For instance, one of the activities is to install four quick charging stations. “The programmes are not in keeping with the lofty names,” he said.

The Opposition has pointed out that the 12th Plan, which is the last mile towards graduation from LDC is not geared towards achieving self-reliance. 


For a least developed country, a GDP target of 5 to 6 percent is very conservative, according to the Opposition.

This was also raised in the Parliament.

However, the Prime Minster claimed that the country’s development philosophy is Gross National Happiness and that the GDP yardstick is not important. The DNT, he had said is center-left party and that it will invest in social sectors, which would not result in GDP expansion. Lyonchhen also claimed that GDP growth in double digit is not achievable since the GDP base has increased substantially compared with the 10th Plan.

For a developed nation, a GDP growth of 2-3 percent is tremendous, Dorji Wangdi said adding that Bhutan’s target should be more ambitious.

The ideology of DPT, he said is GNH. “We are GNH followers and not capitalist,” he said indicating that GNH and GDP can go hand-in-hand.

If the focus is placed on infrastructure and capital investment, he said GDP is bound to grow and that investment on road, health and education is well in keeping with the GNH principles.

This, he said is not the case going by the budget allocation in the 12th Plan. He added that the country’s recurrent expenditure is soaring while only 20 percent of the budget in the 12th Plan is allocated for capital expenditure.

“The statement that GDP should be kept low to achieve GNH does not hold water,” Dorji Wangdi said. “Does the government mean that investment in hydropower does not result in GDP growth?” But the revenue from hydropower, he said, is pumped into social sectors that improve GNH.

“The government has a totally wrong perception and flawed interpretation,” he added.

Opposition Leader, Pema Gyamtsho (PhD) said all plans are well aligned with the four pillars, nine domains and 72 indicators of the GNH and that GDP is an unavoidable yardstick to measure the country’s progress.

But if the government considers GDP as not important, he said there is no GNH index target either. “If we don’t invest in economic growth, we cannot create jobs. Without jobs are we a happy society?”

Opposition’s role

While there is a general feedback that the Opposition and the government get along well, opposition leader said that it cannot be taken as collusion and neither would the party compromise on its role.

But the opposition’s role, he said, was not to criticise and stop the government from functioning. “Where policies are in the best interest of the nation, we will support the government. But if it does not benefit the people, Opposition will provide alternative views and suggestion to improvise things,” he said.

“This also does not mean that we don’t appreciate the gesture extended to us by the government,” he said adding that the cabinet ministers and the Prime Minister always discussed and sought suggestions from the Opposition so far.

Even the first sitting of the third Parliament, he said was very successful with speaker playing a precise non-partisan role.

Tshering Dorji

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News


High Court convicts six men for murder 2019-02-01 06:55:36The High Court sentenced six men from four years to life imprisonment for the murder of a 26-year-old man. The judgement passed yesterday also ordered

Government doing away with Class X cut-off point 2019-02-01 06:55:27Besides compromising the quality of education, doing away with the cut-off point for class 10 could prove to be a huge financial burden to the governm

Fire guts house in Trashigang 2019-02-01 06:55:17A two-storey traditional house in Monkha under Udzorong Gewog in Trashigang was razed to the ground by a fire yesterday. The post Fire guts house in T

Japan donates medical equipment to JDWNRH 2019-01-31 05:53:18The Jigme Dorji Wangchuck National Referral Hospital (JDWNRH) received medical equipment to enhance early detection of hearing impairment and sleep ap

ACC decides not to reinvestigate Learn and Earn 2019-01-31 05:53:01The Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) says they will not reinvestigate "Learn and Earn" programme case. This according to an official from the commis

All 12,033 class X passed students to be 2019-01-30 08:12:37All 12,033 students who have passed class X Bhutan Certificate of Secondary Examination (BCSE) 2018 will be enrolled in Class XI in government and pri

UN to invest US$ 120 M for UNSDPF 2019-01-30 06:46:17Enhancing access to reliable and timely data, improving social services for vulnerable groups, inclusive governance and climate change and disaster ri

BIABPO targets to create 3,000 jobs by 2023 2019-01-30 06:46:11Bhutan Industry Association for Business Process Outsourcing (BIABPO) targets to create 3,000 new jobs for the youths by 2023. This was revealed

Bhutan ranks 25th in 2018 corruption perception index 2019-01-30 06:46:01Bhutan is the 25th least corrupt nation out of 180 countries, according to the Transparency International's 2018 Corruption Perception Index (CPI). B

2018 class 12 results declared 2019-01-29 06:05:08Bhutan Council for School Examinations and Assessment (BCSEA) declared the results for the 2018 Bhutan Higher Secondary Education Examination (BHSEC)

Mangdechhu Hydropower Project completes 90 percent of tunnel 2019-01-16 10:04:17The Mangdechhu Hydropower Project Authority (MHPA) in Trongsa has completed 90 percent of tunnel cleaning works as of yesterday. The post Mangdechhu

ACC implicates two in alleged tax evasion case 2019-01-16 10:04:06The Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) has implicated the Proprietor and Chief Executive Officer of a private cordycep exporting firm, Lhaimetog Export


Free education up to Class XII may breach 2019-02-01 06:34:31The government’s decision to provide free education for all up to Class XII may not be in conformity with the Constitution, the Opposition has s

Admission to Class XI on merit basis 2019-02-01 06:30:56All Class X students who secured an average of 59.4 percent and above would be enrolled in Class XI in public schools according to the education minis

Government confused on wage rate 2019-02-01 06:28:58The government’s proposal to increase the national wage rate would do more damage than good, according to the Opposition. “It’ll hav

Japan donates medical equipment to JDWNRH 2019-02-01 06:28:06The Japanese government donated Polysomnography and Auditory Brain-stem Response equipment for the ENT (ear, nose and throat) department at the Jigme

Plastic ban must be taken seriously 2019-02-01 06:27:01Bhutan banned plastic bags on April 20,1999. It made headlines. Nearly twenty years on, though, we are still talking about the need to outlaw the use

Opposition questions govt’s vision and plans 2019-02-01 06:26:07The government lacks clarity of vision and direction, the Opposition stated yesterday at its first press conference after assuming office. This, the O

Exchange programme to support table tennis players 2019-02-01 06:25:23In a bid to provide exposure, two top table tennis teams from Japan, Citizen and Kyowa Kirin, played with players from Bhutan and Silliguri, India yes

9-year-old completes cross-country cycling race 2019-02-01 06:23:56When the 75kms cross-country cycling race kicked off from the Gelephu Higher Secondary School ground on January 30, people were surprised to see a 9-y

Cut off point for Class X is off  2019-01-31 06:16:20In what is a major policy change, the government has done away with the Class X cut off point and announced that all students who have passed the exam

LG given budgetary flexibility in 12th Plan  2019-01-31 06:14:37Local governments will be able to exercise greater flexibility in planning, budgeting and release of money from this year, according to the recently e

Fourth Pay Commission established 2019-01-11 06:44:13The government has, upon the approval from His Majesty The King, established the fourth Pay Commission yesterday. The time-bound autonomous Pay Com

NC dissects the 12th Plan 2019-01-11 06:42:49In their pursuit to please the voters, political parties could gamble with the principles of gross national happiness (GNH) if national plans and prog

Headline Stories – The

The great cut off point debate 2019-02-01 22:48:58The Education Minister Lyonpo Jai Bir Rai’s announcement on Wednesday that the class 10 cut off point was being done away with, and that the gov

Major Tax reforms in the works to increase 2019-02-01 22:47:58Reform will include increasing PIT slab and introducing GST by next year The Ministry of Finance (MoF) is in the midst of drafting a comprehensive tax

As media faces extinction via e-procurement, PM gives 2019-02-01 22:46:44Opposition says e-procurement cannot be allowed to lead to a weak media There is a great deal of concern within media houses on the revenue impact of

Parents disappointed that Govt & Opposition are on 2019-02-01 22:42:40ACC rejects call for reinvestigation Parents to now file case in court While the dust is yet to settle on the issue regarding the Japan’s &lsquo

His Majesty The King graced the closing ceremony 2019-01-26 01:20:41

Austerity is coming 2019-01-26 01:08:22MoF sends out cost cutting circulars to government agencies as part of a new austerity drive However, its effectiveness is yet to be seen given that s

30 ministerial rank individuals spent Nu 370 mn 2019-01-26 01:04:31MoF to draw up guidelines to put a cap and control this expenditure A ‘Financial Thrift’ report compiled during the interim government per

Parents and students of Japan case request ACC 2019-01-26 00:38:29They expressed dissatisfaction with the government’s response so far The representative of the parents and students of the Japan’s learn a

Bhutan’s hydro has a future provided it can 2019-01-19 00:23:39As Bhutan develops multiple hydro projects an important question to ask is not only on the price of the projects or its loan component and tariff rate

Air quality in Thimphu hits permissible ceiling 2019-01-19 00:20:10Bhutan, for too long has been basking in the glory that came along with the carbon neutral status  which  also has distinguished the country

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.